I know why your marketing is underperforming
Strategy, 16 Jul 2026
We meet business owners every week who tell us the same story: they've spent money on marketing, they've been posting on social, they've paid for ads. And nothing seems to move the needle. In this video David explains why that happens and, more importantly, what to change today.
Most underperforming campaigns aren't failing because the creative is bad or the offer is wrong. They're failing because of inconsistency, weak targeting, and a lack of the Rule of Sevens. The idea that people need to see your brand around seven times before they trust you enough to buy. If you drop off after two or three touchpoints, the whole campaign wastes itself.
Below, David walks through the exact diagnostic Yellow uses when a new client's marketing is underperforming. Watch the video, then check the transcript for the complete breakdown.
Video transcript
I know exactly why your marketing campaigns have not been quite up to your expectations. It's always the same thing whenever we meet with clients and we talk to them about how things have gone in the past and what they want to improve and they show us their old campaigns and they show us what they're doing and um they end up blaming the platform or you know we tried something through the mail or we tried social media or we tried pay-per-click blah blah blah and it's always the same it's always very clear very quickly what the problem was and the problem is you haven't followed the rule of sevens. What that means is basically the days of somebody just say seeing an advert, clicking the advert, going to your website and buying something there and then are over. They're done. It used to be back in the day you could just turn on Adwords and watch the leads and sales come in.
Oh, it was great. But those days are gone. And the rule of sevens means that nobody cares, remembers you, uh, does anything or le definitely isn't in a position to decide that I'm going to buy from this person until they've heard from you about seven times on multiple different platforms because nobody trusts anybody anymore. So, you've got to do a lot of work in your marketing to make them trust you. And you only do that with consistency.
So, they get an email from you, they see you in the press, they see you on social media, they they get another email, they um they uh they get something through the post, they get a phone call from you, um then they get a brochure. It's it's it's only around there where they start thinking, right, we'll use our supplier at the moment. And that that's the other thing. Everybody's already got a supplier for that thing. So, or or they've got a preferred, you know, company that they always use or they just go to Amazon and get it.
So, you need a reason to come away from that supplier and to trust you. And you can't do that straight away. Nobody clicks a Facebook ad and goes, "I trust these people. Just shut up and take my money." Just doesn't happen anymore. So, when we're looking at um people's campaigns and clients campaigns, there's always the same thing.
They just stop too early. And this is where they start playing the blame game with the platform. So for example, this is from a guy who runs a primarily digital creative agency. Uh direct mail is still one of the fantasies of getting return on your investment when it comes to marketing because it's personal. People land it.
It doesn't go into a spam folder. It comes straight in front of you. Um but the problem is people go, "Oh, digital world, direct mail doesn't work anymore. I tried it once and then uh it doesn't work." No, yeah, it does. But why it didn't work for you is probably you sent it to thousands of people uh which is obviously expensive with printing and posting and you sent it once so people would have got that thing and gone oh wow that's interesting that's a good offer I'll do that on payday and then they'll get on with their day they'll just start this was typing on a computer by the way um so once you get to the point where yeah but if they're waiting to payday once you get to that point they've forgotten who you are if you never talk to them And the trick is with things like that is to have a small quality list and regularly send them stuff.
And some people are kind of like, oh well um I don't want to bother anybody. Well, send stuff which won't bother them. Send some something which would be helpful and relevant to them and you know problem solving. That's the stuff that people keep and trust businesses with. And so by the fact you just send one thing with an offer, of course, nobody's going to use it.
They don't trust you. they don't know who you are and they just go with the person down the lane who does it for them. Um, even if they're not that great, but at least it's easy and I trust them a little bit. So, you need to make sure that you're more trustworthy and more of an expert in the industry. And the other thing is stop playing the blame game with the platform.
So, for example, like, well, we did pay-per-click and it was really expensive, so we stopped doing it because of return on investment, which is a completely fair statement, but are you thinking of things like I've had the same heard the same statement about social media. Oh, we tried social media, but you know, we didn't get anything from it. It didn't work. But you got to think as a platform doing its job. the pay-per-click advert, say if it's AdWords or a Facebook ad or something like that, its job is not unless unless it's like even if it's a Google shopping advert, it that click of that ad does not sell the product.
All it does is get people to your website. So if you know you looked at I was doing Facebook ads, it wasn't working. So when we work, we start working with the client and go, "Okay, so who are we targeting?" And if you're targeting the right people, okay, that's great. All right, what was your message? And then if you said your message was great, then great.
Then that's part part of it. But if something wasn't working, that means that it was the website's fault in terms of if you're not getting sales. But pay-per-click is not that's not it. Its job was to get that you seen and clicked to the website. So we look at things and think, well, you're getting plenty of traffic and your message is good and your platform works and you're targeting the right people, but you're not getting the sales.
Your website's rubbish. You need to make sure that you can target people with a good message, but they need to go to a sales tool that actually makes them get in touch. Is your website that there's not enough um data capture forms? Is there not enough? Have you not got uh remarketing code on there so people follow you afterwards and make sure that you get your um that people are seeing adverts for you on Facebook and YouTube and Google and everything.
So, it's not it's not blaming the platform. We need to look at what is the job of the platform. Social media is a traffic source of trust building tool, a communication tool. But its job is not really to sell. People don't go on Facebook to buy things.
They go on there to, you know, read interesting things. But being delivered to your website, your website is the sales tool. So, what you need to do instead of stop using so uh pay-per-click and social or whatever, you need to pause whatever's paid on there and split test your website and keep tweaking it until your conversion rate goes up. And so, going back to the bit at the beginning, while you're doing that, what's what's the seven points that you're meeting people? So, if you're doing a couple of sending a couple of emails out, probably not going to do that much.
If you send uh one thing through the post, not going to do so much. You did one post on social media. Do you really think that's going to do anything? No, it's not. You need to build up trust, add consistency, and follow the rule of sevens.
Don't take silence as no, but add consistency and quality to your marketing, and your marketing will perform better. Don't take silence as no. Keep going.